BUY/SELL/TRADE
KEEPIN IT REAL EDITION
Have cards to move? Bring them in. We offer straightforward in-store value reviews for sports cards, Pokémon, Magic: The Gathering, select singles, slabs, and collections.
Our offers are based on current market value, condition, authenticity, demand, resale potential, and what makes sense for the shop. Translation: we love the hobby, but we also have to buy what can realistically sell. Sentimental value is real — unfortunately, it does not always show up in the comps. Keepin it real
All Star Cards is here to keep things honest, fair, and collector-friendly. We’ll give you a clear answer, not a mystery math magic trick.
A Quick Heads-Up
Before you bring items in, here are a few helpful things to know about what we typically buy and what we may pass on.
Verified Sealed Product
We generally do not buy sealed product from unknown or unverified sources. With the amount of resealed and questionable product circulating, we stick with trusted distributors, vendors, and sources we can verify.
Bulk Card Reality
We also may pass on certain bulk or mass-produced sports cards, especially many late 1980s and early 1990s cards. Some are great for nostalgia. Some are great for memories. Some are, respectfully, worth about as much as the shoebox they came in. We’ll still take a look and be honest with you.
We’ll still take a look, give you a straightforward answer, and let you know what makes sense based on current demand and condition.
No Appointment Needed
No appointment is required. You are welcome to stop by during store hours. For larger collections, calling ahead is recommended so we can make sure someone has time to review them properly.
What We Consider
We buy select sports cards, Pokémon cards, Magic: The Gathering cards, graded cards, singles, and certain collectible items. We may also consider other collectible categories depending on demand, condition, and resale potential.
Selling FAQ
Helpful answers before you stop by the shop.
Do I need an appointment?
No appointment is required. You are welcome to stop by during store hours. For larger collections, calling ahead is recommended so we can make sure someone has time to review them properly.
What kinds of cards do you buy?
We buy select sports cards, Pokémon cards, Magic: The Gathering cards, graded cards, singles, and certain collectible items. We may also consider other collectible categories depending on demand, condition, and resale potential.
Do you buy entire collections?
Sometimes, but not every collection is a fit. We buy what is likely to sell, which may include individual singles, graded cards, sealed items from verified sources, or portions of a collection. If a full collection makes sense, we’ll let you know.
How is value determined?
Value is based on condition, authenticity, current market demand, recent comparable sales, resale potential, and how well the items fit our current buying needs. Market value changes, so today’s offer may not be the same as last month’s internet rumor.
Can I sell sealed product?
Generally, no — unless it comes from a reputable and verifiable source. Because resealed and questionable products are a real issue throughout the hobby, we primarily rely on distributors and trusted vendors for sealed products.
Where are you located?
All Star Cards is located at:
8781 Cuyamaca Street
Santee, CA 92071
United States